Sections

Top Stories
News
Student Life
Science & Environment
Arts & Entertainment

Dining Out
Etcetera
Opinion
People & Places
Lifestyles
Sports 

Information
Clubs list
Calendar of Events
Photo Gallery
Sports

Baseball
Basketball
Cross Country
Softball
Tennis
Volleyball

Hot Links
HPU
Kalamalama Home

Eyewitness to terror, alumnus recollects
by David Levithan, HPU alumnus

New York City, Sept. 11, 11:33 a.m.
There is no good way to begin. The word “unbelievable” is not enough. It’s not even close. Here is the sequence of events as I experienced them.

I was at work, writing e-mail, listening to music. Someone came by my office and said a plane had just hit the World Trade Center. We ran up to the 11th floor, here at 555 Broadway, to our cafeteria, which has an unblocked view of the Twin Towers. I thought it was a joke. And then, right before I got there, I thought that it probably wasn’t a joke. Then I saw it.
Click on image for photo gallery

I rounded a corner and looked out the window and saw the dark, jagged hole – a crater – in the side of the right hand tower. It looked, we all said, like a special effect from a big-budget science fiction movie. That was our first way of grasping it.

We were still in disbelief. We hadn’t moved to unbelief yet. We just stared. More people came up and stopped in shock. We all just stared.

In the shadow of the crater we could see the fire. It seemed so small to us. It wasn’t until we thought about it, that we realized that flames were stories high. And the hole itself was the size of our building.

I will admit here that I went to get my camera, not from any morbid attraction, not for profit nor for anyone but myself. I knew – even here, at the beginning, which seems like almost nothing compared to everything that came after – that this was going to be one of the true historical moments of my life, that the personal and the historical were converging. (“Where were you when you first heard . . . ?) And here I was, not hearing, but seeing.

Other people had heard the first plane, had wondered why it was flying so low. Many heard the crash and thought it was a bomb going off or a gas pipe explosion.

I took my camera and went up to the roof and took pictures. So I would remember it right. So I would know I was there.

I was not thinking in terms of people. That was too horrifying. I hadn’t yet made that leap. I couldn’t. I thought in terms of the building. We said, “It’s amazing. It’s still standing. I can’t believe this.”

And then . . . The middle of the second tower shot out in flames. We gasped. We covered our mouths. We shuddered. Some of us cried out.

I did not see the second plane. I wasn’t looking at that particular place at that particular moment. The impact was on the other side from us, so there was a minute, maybe less, when I thought that somehow the fire had leapt from one building to the other.

It made no sense. But of course I didn’t want it to make sense. Then someone said he had seen another plane. That’s when we crossed over to disbelief. I will always remember standing there.

I will remember other people on the roof. I will remember a friend who made eye contact, and then she began to cry. She was the first that I saw crying. She had a cell phone in her hand.

I went inside (all windows, full view) and saw two other friends. We talked some more about the buildings, about disbelief. And then, as the radio began to say there was a second plane, we talked about evil.

About pure, unmitigated evil.

We couldn’t make comparisons. They all seemed too weak. Knowing we couldn’t erase what had happened, we at least wanted the consolation of an accident, a randomness, something that wasn’t of any design. The truth was inconceivable because it had been conceived.

Horror on top of horror. Realizing each row of each tower was a floor. Each slit was a window. Realizing that there was nothing anyone could do.

Sirens. We could hear sirens. I went downstairs and put down my camera; I was through with it. As I got to my desk, someone said something about the Pentagon.

I moved to an office with a TV instead (brought into work for the U.S. Open). In poor reception black-and-white, we tried to piece together what was happening.

I called my parents and then came back. We wondered what to do, where to go. The bridges and tunnels were now closed. If you didn’t live in Manhattan, there was no way to get home.

Then the word from the television. Collapsing... We ran upstairs, back to the roof. As we did, other people ran down, sobbing, distraught. I pushed through the door, I saw friends in shock, and then I looked past them and saw the lone tower and the cloud of smoke and dust. Then I turned and saw the TV set that they had put there, and I saw the tower fall.

I cannot think of a single word to describe what we felt. Perhaps in some other language there is a word for a world that is terribly wrong. That stunned feeling of disbelief and abandonment and shock and horror and distress.

I stood in the center. I looked around. We were all crying now. The less distraught were hugging the more distraught. We just couldn’t.... We just didn’t.... I don’t want to write with too heavy a hand here. I know it’s too early to tell. But I will say this: When that first tower fell, it took something away from us. It is something we won’t get back again, at least for a while. Maybe that’s the moment that our disbelief turned slightly to belief.

And we knew, in that belief, that the safety we had known was diminished, that evil had won and fear would tread the world.

I saw people cry whom I never thought I would see cry. I saw a skyline that I never, ever imagined I would see. I saw smoke. I saw the TV repeat it and repeat it and repeat it. I shuddered. I was so glad I was not alone. At this point, someone decided to evacuate our building. We got our stuff, walked down the central staircase, went outside to chaos. Nobody knew what to do. Was it safer to walk the streets or stay in the building? People who lived close opened their homes to people who didn’t live close. Our publisher came around and told us we could go back in. Still, nobody knew what to do.

I decided to stay. Then I decided to go. Then, when my friend Kate said she was staying, I decided to stay. Kate’s family was staying near the Towers, so the priority was to make sure they were okay. (They were; God bless voicemail for letting us know.) When we walked back from outside, the TV in the lobby showed the second Tower falling. Again – disbelief. And horrible belief.

2:35 p.m.
The office is nearly empty now. People are walking across bridges, walking more than 100 blocks to get home. There is only one way to get to New Jersey – a ferry – so I will probably stay in the city for the night.

We are just starting to process what happened. We are just starting to comprehend this thing that defies comprehension. I wonder what it’s like for those of you who only saw this on a TV screen. How surreal it must seem, like a bad movie, completely unreal yet completely real. As the stories come trickling in second- and third-hand, I realize that even my vantage point had some distance. One friend saw the second airplane hit as she stood in front of the Municipal Building. Another friend was in the lobby of the tower when the first plane hit.

I cannot comprehend – not now – what our lives are going to be like. We are not made to comprehend having so many things gone so suddenly. Just as it was hard to know how to begin this, it’s hard to know how to end it. Because there is no end in sight. Just questions and bewilderment and a deep sadness that I don’t really want to touch. I keep going back to that first moment, seeing the black hole on the tower, seeing the site of the first crash. That image, that one image, is what I am thinking about right now.

That tower is our history, our lives, all the minutiae and security and hope. And that black hole is what we’re feeling. It is what has happened. It will affect us in ways we can’t even begin to get our minds around right now. I know all of you are experiencing this in your own way, with your own stories and thoughts and emotions. I really wrote this more for myself, so I will always have my first reaction, before I learn anything more.

I guess I’ll end with a sentence I always write, but which seems to mean more as I write it this minute: I hope you all are well.

 

 

©2001, Kalamalama, the HPU Student Newspaper. All rights reserved.
 
This site designed & maintained by Rick Bernico.